Civics
Gov-Politics

Time for a Check-Up: Should Politicians Over 75 Pass a Mental Competency Test?

The ship of state needs a steady hand at the wheel, not someone who’s driving on cruise control. After all, none of us want to be passengers on a boat where the captain’s compass is stuck in 1975.

Ladies and gentlemen, gather ’round! It’s time to talk about a political hot potato, or perhaps, in this case, a wrinkled one. As the halls of power start looking more like a grandparent’s reunion, a pressing question emerges: Should politicians over 75 years old be required to pass a mental competency test? Let’s dive into this debate and have some fun while we’re at it.

The Silver-Haired Statesmen

First off, let’s give credit where it’s due. There’s no denying that wisdom often comes with age. Politicians who’ve been around since the days of black-and-white TV bring with them a wealth of knowledge, historical perspective, and—if nothing else—some truly wild stories from the pre-Instagram era. These are the folks who remember when filibustering meant actually talking for hours, not just tweeting furiously.

But while we respect our elder politicians, the demands of modern leadership require more than just spinning yarns about the good ol’ days. In a world where policy decisions are made at the speed of a Wi-Fi signal, mental agility matters more than whether you can still name all the cast members from Leave It to Beaver. As charming as nostalgia is, we need leaders who can tell us where the future’s going, not just where we’ve been.

The 2024 Presidential Debate: The Battle of Buffers

And speaking of knowing where we’re going, let’s pause to reflect on the 2024 Presidential Debate—a spectacle ruled by pauses, verbal fumbles, and some creative interpretations of reality. On one side, we had Joe Biden, a spry 82, with more pauses than a buffering YouTube video, leaving viewers to wonder if he was solving an equation or waiting for his train of thought. Conversely, a youthful 78, Donald Trump delivered his usual mix of confidence and confusion, leaving fact-checkers in despair.

Politicians mental competency Trump and Biden split screen
Caricatures by DonkeyHotey, Flickr, CC 2.0 license

It wasn’t a debate; it was a contest of who could make less sense. Biden even answered a question from four years ago, while Trump boasted about his cognitive test memory sequence, “Person, woman, man, camera, TV,” as if it were foreign policy advice. As the moderators struggled for coherence, the audience wondered if the candidates needed a moderator for their thoughts.

Which brings us to the real question: How do we ensure our leaders are sharp enough to lead?

The Case for Competency Checks

Enter the proposal for mental competency tests. Now, we’re not asking our senior leaders to solve Rubik’s Cubes blindfolded or ace some viral TikTok dance—though let’s be honest, that would be entertaining. This isn’t about forcing them into the gig economy but ensuring they’re still firing on all cognitive cylinders. Think of it like checking under the hood of an old car—you love it, but you want to make sure it can still hit the highway without sputtering out.

Because let’s be real—it’s not about the age; it’s about the mileage. Just like a classic car, politicians need regular check-ups to stay roadworthy. You wouldn’t drive a vintage Corvette cross-country without checking the brakes, so why should we let our government leaders cruise along without ensuring the mental engine is still in top shape?

Annual “State of Mind” Address

So, what’s the solution? We propose the annual “State of Mind” address. Picture this: Every politician over 75 sits down for a cognitive check-up—nothing too scary, just a bit of memory recall, some decision-making exercises, and a quick test to see if they know what year it is. Think of it like a yearly doctor’s visit but for the brain.

But wait—let’s make it fun. How about turning it into primetime TV? “The Cognitive Games” could pit our seasoned senators against each other in a Jeopardy!-style mental marathon. “I’ll take ‘basic reasoning’ for 500, Alex!” Forget fundraising dinners—how about a national competition where politicians battle for bragging rights and a few neural pathways? The winner could even choose a charity or, better yet, direct funding to something useful like student loan forgiveness or climate change research.

Addressing the Critics

Now, before you cry ageism, let’s be clear—it’s not about being anti-senior. It’s about ensuring our leaders can keep pace with the world they’re governing. We’re not asking them to run marathons just to prove they can still handle the everyday pressure of running the country. After all, if your airline pilot hadn’t passed a competency test in decades, you’d be a little worried at 35,000 feet, right?

And let’s not pretend we haven’t had moments where we wondered, “Did they really just say that?” It’s not the viral TikTok star we’re worried about—it’s the folks running the country. Congress sometimes moves slower than a DMV line at lunchtime, which begs the question: if the opposite of “pro” is “con,” does that make Congress the opposite of progress? Maybe that’s why it wouldn’t hurt to make sure all the gears are still turning smoothly upstairs.

Politicians mental competency Caricature of Mitch McConnell
DonkeyHotey, Flickr CC 2.0 license

 

The Wisdom of Youthful Innovation

But let’s not get carried away. Wisdom is valuable, and seasoned politicians have lived through history in a way that younger ones haven’t. That said, blending seasoned wisdom with youthful energy might give us the best of both worlds. After all, while you might not be able to teach an old dog new tricks, you can definitely make sure they remember where they buried the bone.

In fact, innovation and adaptability might be precisely what the doctor ordered. As the world speeds up, we need leaders who can keep up with the times. So, how about a compromise? Instead of solely relying on politicians who’ve been in office since rotary phones were a thing, let’s mix in some fresh faces who know their way around an iPhone—and maybe throw in a mental check-up for good measure.

Embracing Accountability

So, should politicians over 75 be required to pass a mental competency test? Absolutely. It’s not an insult to age; it’s a recognition of the responsibility that comes with leadership. If we expect them to make decisions that affect millions, is it too much to ask that they prove they’re still mentally sharp enough to do so?

In the end, this is about accountability. The ship of state needs a steady hand at the wheel, not someone who’s driving on cruise control. After all, none of us want to be passengers on a boat where the captain’s compass is stuck in 1975.

1 Shares
Pin
Share
Share
Tweet